http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=pl ... cA0#t=2191 <----- the part I first shit myself playing that game =P
but anyways I've actually played them all! (well except penumbra)
-Doom 3 - was mostly darkness + jump scares I recently just played it through again with a few new graphic and lighting mods
-Dead Space - 1 had space babies (should I say more) and 2 wasn't as scary as 1 you could see the more action parts of it coming in
-Amnesia - I did play and it freaked me out a little so I didn't play it any more
-Penumbra - I haven't played but I think I know what game it is and I think it is scary from what I remember (might give it a go)
-Metro 2033 -not scary at all!
-F3AR - Terrible it had nothing of the scariness of the 1st and 2nd games, it was more of a generic shooter than anything else basically there to cap off a story, mind the story wasn't that bad but it just isn't the same =(
Ill probably give Amnesia another look at, I cant quite remember what was scary about it (maybe the red goo that was all over walls and floor!) and I'll see where i can get a copy of penumbra from. Tbh I think Jonnie should play and get rid of his phobias of scary games =P